Tuesday, December 30, 2008

A massacre


1 death Palestinian, 2 death Palestinians including women and children, 3 death Palestinians including women and children, 4 death Palestinians including women and children, 5 death Palestinians including women and children,

Bradley Burston wrote yesterday in the Israelian newspaper Haaretz:

I want to apologize for the unforgivable.

It is time for us to stop "understanding" why we kill so many Palestinian civilians.
It is time for us to stop explaining away the deaths we excuse as the unfortunate and incidental by-product of a terrible war.


6 death Palestinians including women and children, 7 death Palestinians including women and children, 8 death Palestinians including women and children, 9 death Palestinians including women and children, 10 death Palestinians including women and children, 11 death Palestinians including women and children, 12 death Palestinians including women and children, 13 death Palestinians including women and children, 14 death Palestinians including women and children, 15 death Palestinians including women and children, 16 death Palestinians including women and children, 17 death Palestinians including women and children, 18 death Palestinians including women and children, 19 death Palestinians including women and children, 20 death Palestinians including women and children,

If it had been only an isolated incident, a tragic aberration, I would have kept my peace, said nothing, just moved on.

But the same crime, the same - let's call it by its real name - atrocity, has been committed time and again, under the same circumstances, for the same reasons, with the same indefensible result.

Someone in an Israelian Defence Force uniform, in a position of responsibility, gave an order.
We will probably never know who.
Nor will we know who loaded the shell into the tank gun, if that was, indeed what happened, or who armed the air-to-surface missile, if that was what happened, who sighted the target, who gave the order to fire, who carried it out.

21 death Palestinians including women and children, 22 death Palestinians including women and children, 23 death Palestinians including women and children, 24 death Palestinians including women and children, 25 death Palestinians including women and children, 26 death Palestinians including women and children, 27 death Palestinians including women and children, 28 death Palestinians including women and children, 29 death Palestinians including women and children, 30 death Palestinians including women and children, 40 death Palestinians including women and children, 50 death Palestinians including women and children,

The army said it fired two missiles at Palestinian militants near the tin shack of the Abu Meatik family, detonating explosives carried by the militants, sparking a "secondary explosion" that struck the home.

Witnesses said that a tank shell sheared through the roof and killed everyone inside, among them Rudina Abu Meatik, 6, her brothers, Saleh, 4 and Mousab, 15 months, and her three-year-old sister, Hana, 3.


60 death Palestinians including women and children, 70 death Palestinians including women and children, 80 death Palestinians including women and children,

What we do know is that a mother in Beit Hanoun, a devastated area of northern Gaza from which Qassams and mortars are fired at Israel, was seeing to the breakfast of her four small children Monday morning when their world exploded.

We know that they are all dead.


90 death Palestinians including women and children, 100 death Palestinians including women and children, 101 death Palestinians including women and children, 102 death Palestinians including women and children, 103 death Palestinians including women and children, 104 death Palestinians including women and children, 105 death Palestinians including women and children, 106 death Palestinians including women and children, 107 death Palestinians including women and children, 108 death Palestinians including women and children,

We console ourselves, here on the Israeli side of the border, that, unlike the suicide bomber, the box cutter terrorist, the drive-by machine gunner, the Merkaz Harav gunman, the deaths of the children and their mother in Beit Hanoun were a terrible case of bad fortune.

109 death Palestinians including women and children, 110 death Palestinians including women and children, 111 death Palestinians including women and children, 112 death Palestinians including women and children, 113 death Palestinians including women and children, 114 death Palestinians including women and children, 115 death Palestinians including women and children, 116 death Palestinians including women and children, 117 death Palestinians including women and children, 118 death Palestinians including women and children, 119 death Palestinians including women and children,

We salve our doubts by stressing - and this is true - that the Israeli army never intentionally targets non-combatants. We protect our fragile consciences by suppressing case after case of Palestinian civilian casualties.

120 death Palestinians including women and children, 121 death Palestinians including women and children, 122 death Palestinians including women and children, 123 death Palestinians including women and children, 124 death Palestinians including women and children, 125 death Palestinians including women and children, 126 death Palestinians including women and children, 127 death Palestinians including women and children, 128 death Palestinians including women and children, 129 death Palestinians including women and children, 130 death Palestinians including women and children, 131 death Palestinians including women and children, 132 death Palestinians including women and children, 133 death Palestinians including women and children, 134 death Palestinians including women and children,

We deflect our guilt by shifting the blame to Hamas, to the Jihad, even - and for this I apologize seventy-fold - to the failure of Palestinian civilians to rise up and stop the terrorists.

135 death Palestinians including women and children, 136 death Palestinians including women and children, 137 death Palestinians including women and children, 138 death Palestinians including women and children, 139 death Palestinians including women and children, 140 death Palestinians including women and children, 141 death Palestinians including women and children, 142 death Palestinians including women and children, 143 death Palestinians including women and children, 144 death Palestinians including women and children, 145 death Palestinians including women and children, 146 death Palestinians including women and children, 147 death Palestinians including women and children, 148 death Palestinians including women and children, 149 death Palestinians including women and children, 150 death Palestinians including women and children, 151 death Palestinians including women and children, 152 death Palestinians including women and children, 153 death Palestinians including women and children, 154 death Palestinians including women and children, 155 death Palestinians including women and children,

We are prepared to excuse it again and again. We excused it when we heard the news today, just as we excused it in November, 2006, when an Israelian Defence Force artillery piece killed 19 people in Beit Hanoun, some of them children still sleeping in their beds when the shell hit.

No more.

156 death Palestinians including women and children, 157 death Palestinians including women and children, 158 death Palestinians including women and children, 159 death Palestinians including women and children,
160 death Palestinians including women and children, 161 death Palestinians including women and children, 162 death Palestinians including women and children, 163 death Palestinians including women and children, 164 death Palestinians including women and children, 165 death Palestinians including women and children, 166 death Palestinians including women and children, 167 death Palestinians including women and children, 168 death Palestinians including women and children, 169 death Palestinians including women and children, 170 death Palestinians including women and children, 171 death Palestinians including women and children, 172 death Palestinians including women and children, 173 death Palestinians including women and children, 174 death Palestinians including women and children, 175 death Palestinians including women and children, 176 death Palestinians including women and children, 177 death Palestinians including women and children, 178 death Palestinians including women and children, 179 death Palestinians including women and children,

It would pay, in this regard, for us to review the reasons why Palestinian mortars and Qassam rockets fired at civilian centers are considered a war crime. "Because Qassams are not capable of accurate targeting, it is unlawful to use them in or near areas populated with civilians," Human Rights Watch said after a Qassam killed a Sderot mother of two children, days after the 19, mostly women and children, were killed in Beit Hanoun.

It would pay, in this regard, for us to recognize that despite cutting edge technology, we can aim neither tank shells nor missile with assurance.

180 death Palestinians including women and children, 181 death Palestinians including women and children, 182 death Palestinians including women and children, 183 death Palestinians including women and children, 184 death Palestinians including women and children, 185 death Palestinians including women and children, 186 death Palestinians including women and children, 187 death Palestinians including women and children, 188 death Palestinians including women and children, 189 death Palestinians including women and children, 190 death Palestinians including women and children, 191 death Palestinians including women and children, 192 death Palestinians including women and children, 193 death Palestinians including women and children, 194 death Palestinians including women and children,

"International humanitarian law prohibits direct attacks against civilians and civilian objects as well as indiscriminate attacks and attacks that cause disproportionate damage to civilians," the organization declared. "A prohibited indiscriminate attack includes using weapons that are incapable of discriminating between civilians and combatants or between civilian and military objects."

195 death Palestinians including women and children, 196 death Palestinians including women and children, 197 death Palestinians including women and children, 198 death Palestinians including women and children, 199 death Palestinians including women and children, 200 death Palestinians including women and children, 201 death Palestinians including women and children, 202 death Palestinians including women and children, 203 death Palestinians including women and children, 204 death Palestinians including women and children, 205 death Palestinians including women and children, 206 death Palestinians including women and children, 207 death Palestinians including women and children, 208 death Palestinians including women and children, 209 death Palestinians including women and children, 210 death Palestinians including women and children, 211 death Palestinians including women and children, 212 death Palestinians including women and children, 213 death Palestinians including women and children, 214 death Palestinians including women and children, 215 death Palestinians including women and children, 216 death Palestinians including women and children, 217 death Palestinians including women and children, 218 death Palestinians including women and children, 219 death Palestinians including women and children, 220 death Palestinians including women and children, 221 death Palestinians including women and children, 222 death Palestinians including women and children, 223 death Palestinians including women and children,

We all know why we send in the assault helicopter, and the tank, and the fighter-bomber, and use them against Palestinians. We use them for the same reason we pulled out of Gaza. To spare our own soldiers. We know that occupation takes huge numbers of troops. We use armor against humans in order to limit the exposure of our own soldiers to risk.

The way we use them, however, kills children.

224 death Palestinians including women and children, 225 death Palestinians including women and children, 226 death Palestinians including women and children, 227 death Palestinians including women and children, 228 death Palestinians including women and children, 229 death Palestinians including women and children, 230 death Palestinians including women and children, 231 death Palestinians including women and children, 232 death Palestinians including women and children, 233 death Palestinians including women and children, 234 death Palestinians including women and children, 235 death Palestinians including women and children, 236 death Palestinians including women and children, 237 death Palestinians including women and children, 238 death Palestinians including women and children, 239 death Palestinians including women and children, 240 death Palestinians including women and children, 241 death Palestinians including women and children, 242 death Palestinians including women and children,

And while we're at it, let the Israeli who is stunned and stricken by Palestinian terror, begin to acknowledge that incidental killings of civilians are our shame, our war crime, our suicide bombs, the massacres for which we, virtuous as we believe we are, are directly to blame.

243 death Palestinians including women and children, 244 death Palestinians including women and children, 245 death Palestinians including women and children, 246 death Palestinians including women and children, 247 death Palestinians including women and children, 248 death Palestinians including women and children, 249 death Palestinians including women and children, 250 death Palestinians including women and children, 251 death Palestinians including women and children, 252 death Palestinians including women and children, 253 death Palestinians including women and children, 254 death Palestinians including women and children, 255 death Palestinians including women and children, 256 death Palestinians including women and children, 257 death Palestinians including women and children, 258 death Palestinians including women and children, 259 death Palestinians including women and children, 260 death Palestinians including women and children, 261 death Palestinians including women and children, 262 death Palestinians including women and children, 263 death Palestinians including women and children, 264 death Palestinians including women and children, 265 death Palestinians including women and children, 266 death Palestinians including women and children,

U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon condemned Hamas for the rocket attacks, but also had strong words for Israel.

"While recognizing Israel's right to defend itself, I have also condemned the excessive use of force by Israel in Gaza. The suffering caused to civilian populations as a result of the large-scale violence and destruction that have taken place over the past few days has saddened me profoundly,"

267 death Palestinians including women and children, 268 death Palestinians including women and children, 269 death Palestinians including women and children, 270 death Palestinians including women and children, 271 death Palestinians including women and children,272 death Palestinians including women and children, 273 death Palestinians including women and children, 274 death Palestinians including women and children, 275 death Palestinians including women and children, 276 death Palestinians including women and children, 277 death Palestinians including women and children,

The U.N. Security Council called for both sides to immediately end the violence, but Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert said Sunday that the campaign could last "for some time," and his Cabinet voted to call up 7,000 reservists.

278 death Palestinians including women and children, 279 death Palestinians including women and children, 280 death Palestinians including women and children, 281 death Palestinians including women and children, 282 death Palestinians including women and children, 283 death Palestinians including women and children, 284 death Palestinians including women and children, 285 death Palestinians including women and children, 286 death Palestinians including women and children, 287 death Palestinians including women and children, 288 death Palestinians including women and children,

"It's very bad, people are running in all directions because of the bombings that are happening everywhere," Karen AbuZayd said from Gaza City.
AbuZayd is the commissioner-general of the U.N. Relief and Works Agency, which provides assistance to about 80 percent of Gaza's 1.5 million residents.
289 death Palestinians including women and children, 290 death Palestinians including women and children, 291 death Palestinians including women and children, 292 death Palestinians including women and children, 293 death Palestinians including women and children, 294 death Palestinians including women and children, 295 death Palestinians including women and children, 296 death Palestinians including women and children, 297 death Palestinians including women and children, 298 death Palestinians including women and children, 299 death Palestinians including women and children, 300 death Palestinians including women and children, 301 death Palestinians including women and children, 302 death Palestinians including women and children, 303 death Palestinians including women and children,

Iyad Nasr, the Red Cross spokesman, said Israeli sanctions had left Gaza's hospitals "almost incapable of functioning" even before the weekend's attacks, and those facilities are now "bleeding every resource available."
304 death Palestinians including women and children, 305 death Palestinians including women and children, 306 death Palestinians including women and children, 307 death Palestinians including women and children, 308 death Palestinians including women and children, 309 death Palestinians including women and children, 310 death Palestinians including women and children, 311 death Palestinians including women and children, 312 death Palestinians including women and children, 313 death Palestinians including women and children, 314 death Palestinians including women and children, 315 death Palestinians including women and children, 316 death Palestinians including women and children,

Angry protests took place in several cities around the world on Sunday against Israel after its air strikes in Gaza killed at least 270 people and wounded hundreds more. In London, hundreds of demonstrators battled riot police in an attempt to enter the Israeli Embassy, according to media reports.
317 death Palestinians including women and children, 318 death Palestinians including women and children, 319 death Palestinians including women and children, 320 death Palestinians including women and children, 321 death Palestinians including women and children, 322 death Palestinians including women and children, 323 death Palestinians including women and children, 324 death Palestinians including women and children, 325 death Palestinians including women and children, 326 death Palestinians including women and children, 327 death Palestinians including women and children,

"We are in an all-out war against Hamas," Barak told a special session of the Knesset, the Israeli parliament.

328 death Palestinians including women and children, 329 death Palestinians including women and children, 330 death Palestinians including women and children, 331 death Palestinians including women and children, 332 death Palestinians including women and children, 333 death Palestinians including women and children,

Gaza families were sleeping in stairwells and corridors in hopes of avoiding the Israeli airstrikes, which have targeted Gaza City's largest university, as well as mosques that Israel claimed were being used to store weapons, build rockets or hide militants. Israel announced Monday that it would also attack private residences if they're used to house militants.
334 death Palestinians including women and children, 335 death Palestinians including women and children, 336 death Palestinians including women and children, 337 death Palestinians including women and children, 338 death Palestinians including women and children,

In messages that have left many Palestinians rattled, Israel has been placing calls to Gaza residents to personally warn them that their homes, or adjacent buildings, were targets.

Among those trapped in their homes was Wafa Kannan, a 27-year-old Gaza City resident who's been camping out in a narrow apartment corridor with her mother and two brothers since the strikes began on Saturday.

Over the weekend, Kannan's mother received a recorded call on her cell phone from the Israeli military. When she heard who was calling, she hung up. Minutes later, the same call came to the landline in her apartment warning her to leave if she was storing weapons.

339 death Palestinians including women and children, 340 death Palestinians including women and children, 341 death Palestinians including women and children, 342 death Palestinians including women and children, 343 death Palestinians including women and children, 344 death Palestinians including women and children, 345 death Palestinians including women and children.

White House spokesman Gordon Johndroe defended the Israeli attack on Gaza.
But added that the Bush administration was urging Israel to avoid civilian casualties.
346 death Palestinians including women and children, 347 death Palestinians including women and children, 348 death Palestinians including women and children, 349 death Palestinians including women and children, 350 death Palestinians including women and children, 351 death Palestinians including women and children, 352 death Palestinians including women and children, 353 death Palestinians including women and children, 354 death Palestinians including women and children, 355 death Palestinians including women and children, 356 death Palestinians including women and children, 357 death Palestinians including women and children, 358 death Palestinians including women and children, 359 death Palestinians including women and children, 360 death Palestinians including women and children.

And more than 1.400 Palestinian men, women and children injured.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

For the full story of Bradley Burston in the Israelian newspaper Haaretz, click on
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/978661.html






.

4 comments:

Croft said...

Thank you for doing this Michael. The world is turning it's back to this atrocity while Lame Duck Bush defends it.

Anonymous said...

I'm by no means an expert in Middle Estern Affairs, or in foreign affairs in general, but are we to completely ignore the fact that Israel was not the party that broke the cease fire. It seems that they were fired upon first.

miked said...

One of your best pieces yet.

And yet...

what next?

Is there hope for a peaceful solution? Both sides are culpable here.

Fred Wishnie said...

Your posts on this are so painful to read. But what is to be done? The mix of historical and religious animosity goes back thousands of years, and unless a Solomonic settlement can be forced, this will go on for another thousand.

Each side is equally right and wrong, a pox on both.

Pity the poor children born into this.